The Power of a Question: Why We Give Advice First - and How to Start Asking Better Questions

Take a look at your daily life. How much of your time do you spend truly leading, and how much is spent simply managing, telling people what to do?

Traditionally, management and advice have often been about instruction and control. A problem arises at home or at work, and you provide the solution. In the moment, this can feel fast and efficient. But in the long run, it can create an exhausting cycle of dependency. You end up carrying the weight of everyone else’s problems, constantly putting out fires, and feeling responsible for having all the answers. Meanwhile, the people around you - your team, partner, or children - may sit back and wait for your next instruction.

If you want to build high-performing teams and fulfilling relationships, it is essential to master the art of asking questions instead of telling people what to do.

Why do we give advice so quickly?

Why is it so difficult to ask questions instead of immediately giving advice? Our brains like to feel smart. We want to solve problems quickly, and we often feel an urgent need to share our own ideas. There are two main (biological) reasons for this:

The fixing habit

People often want to solve problems quickly because it makes them feel helpful and useful. Finding a solution can trigger dopamine, the brain’s “feel-good” chemical. Over time, this can become a loop: the brain craves that rewarding feeling and repeats the behaviour that produces it. And any behaviour we repeat often enough becomes an automatic habit.

Comfort, control, and safety

Throughout history, appearing knowledgeable has often increased a person’s social status. If we do not offer an immediate solution, we may worry that others will think we do not know what we are doing. Feeling smart can give us a sense of power, status, and control over our world. Asking questions, on the other hand, means acknowledging that we may not have the answer. That can feel uncomfortable or even unsafe.

Giving advice can seem social, kind, and empathetic because it appears that we are helping someone. However, the underlying reasons we give advice are often more about ourselves than about the other person. They may be connected to our own need for safety, status, or control.

When we constantly manage or advise, we can create dependency. We may block other people’s growth, create frustration for ourselves, and miss opportunities for genuine connection. So, there is much more at stake than we may think: our own energy and freedom, the quality of our relationships, and both our self-esteem and that of the people around us!

How to switch from advising to asking questions

  • Pause and breathe. Wait a few seconds before you speak or type. Create space between the problem and your response.
  • Embrace the discomfort of not advising. Remind yourself that your job is not to fix everything. Your job is to support growth, both your own and that of others. three.
  • Start with curiosity. Ask open-ended questions. Use what, how, or can you tell me more about… instead of saying, “You should…” For example, instead of saying, “You should do it this way,” try asking, “What options do you see for approaching this problem?”

The ripple effect of a powerful question

Simply asking questions can open up a world of possibilities. When we encourage others to reflect and discover their own solutions, we empower them to take ownership of their actions. This approach not only fosters independence, but also builds confidence and critical-thinking skills. Each question can create a ripple effect: it encourages movement, sparks reflection, and inspires people to explore new ideas. This simple shift engages the other person while also supporting their growth and learning.

And this shift is precisely what lies at the heart of a coaching approach.

Why coaching matters

A coaching approach can make a meaningful difference for your employees, colleagues, children - and for you.

  • It stimulates critical thinking and self-confidence. Open-ended questions encourage people to explore possibilities and develop their problem-solving skills.
  • It creates ownership and independence. When people are encouraged to find their own solutions, they take greater responsibility for their choices and become more independent.
  • It builds trust and equality in relationships. A coaching approach creates an environment of trust and respect, in which people feel heard, valued, and equal.

Do you see how different these outcomes are from the results that constant advising can create? The first step is simply to get out of your own way and interrupt the habit of giving advice.

Ready to learn how to ask better questions?

Want to learn how to do this - and how to ask the right questions at the right time? Join our Expert in Coaching Program, starting this November. This comprehensive program is designed to equip you with the skills to become a transformational coach. You will learn how to create growth in others while strengthening your own leadership capabilities. Take the first step towards elevating your leadership and unlocking the potential in yourself and the people around you.

👉 Discover the Expert in Coaching Program and claim your spot. Let’s embrace the power of questions together and create meaningful change in our organisations and communities.